Log In Create Account

Philippine Bar review · Question

Practice question: Primary Jurisdiction

Multiple Choice Medium

Practice question

A court suit presents a purely legal challenge to an agency’s rulemaking measure rather than asking an agency to adjudicate technical disputed facts. Counsel insists primary jurisdiction automatically bars the suit solely because the rule came from an agency. Which is best?
  1. Every agency-issued rule is immune from court challenge
  2. Every legal question must be decided first by the agency in all cases
  3. Rulemaking and adjudication are identical for this purpose
  4. The agency can conclusively determine its own constitutional power
  5. The nature of the challenged power and issue matters; an automatic primary-jurisdiction bar does not follow

Legal references

  • G.R.202275, July17 2018, main decision, quasi-legislative/quasi-judicial distinction: https://lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2018/jul2018/gr_202275_2018.html

Answer this question in flashcards to review your response and continue practicing.