Log In Create Account

Philippine Bar review · Question

Practice question: Personal Comfort Doctrine

Multiple Choice Hard

Practice question

An onboard injury claimant proves a reasonable brief act of personal comfort but argues that invoking the doctrine dispenses with all evidence of a connection between the injury and that act. How should the argument be assessed?
  1. The doctrine does not excuse proof of the injury’s relevant employment nexus by substantial evidence
  2. Every alleged injury is automatically proved
  3. The employer must concede any uncorroborated story
  4. The doctrine eliminates causation in every case
  5. All private activities worldwide become employment

Legal references

  • Arguilles v Wilhelmsen GR254586 July10,2023 MAIN: https://lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2023/jul2023/gr_254586_2023.html Personal-comfort rationale and ordinary physical demands.
  • Arriesgado v Multinational Maritime GR275424 April29,2026 MAIN: https://lawphil.net/judjuris/juri2026/apr2026/gr_275424_2026.html Employment nexus and substantial evidence.

Answer this question in flashcards to review your response and continue practicing.