Question

Mr. X and Ms. Y have been engaged to be married for several years. They have made various plans for their future together, including purchasing a house and starting a family. However, recently, Mr. X abruptly calls off the engagement and refuses to proceed with the marriage.

In light of this situation, Ms. Y is considering pursuing legal action against Mr. X for breach of promise of marriage. Analyze the following scenarios and determine the rights and remedies available to Ms. Y under the concept of abuse of rights:

1. Scenario 1: Mr. X calls off the engagement because he has unexpectedly inherited a significant amount of debt and believes that marrying Ms. Y would worsen his financial situation.
2. Scenario 2: Mr. X ends the engagement due to a sudden change of heart and realization that he is no longer in love with Ms. Y.
3. Scenario 3: Mr. X terminates the engagement after discovering that Ms. Y has been engaged in fraudulent activities and has concealed important information about her past.