Question

In the case of spouses who wish to make donations in consideration of their marriage, certain requirements must be met to ensure the validity of the donation. Similarly, there are instances when certain donations are considered void in the context of marital property relations. Familiarize yourself with the provisions of the Family Code, particularly Articles 74-81 on the property relations between spouses, as well as Articles 82-83, 86-87, and Sections 43(3) and 50.

Question:

1. Julian and Marissa, a married couple, decided to celebrate their 10th wedding anniversary by renewing their vows. As a gesture of love and commitment, Julian decided to surprise Marissa with a valuable piece of land property, which he registered in Marissa's name. Upon discovering the surprise gift, Marissa was truly touched and grateful to Julian. However, after a year, Julian filed for divorce and claimed that he wants the property to be returned to him. Marissa refused, stating that it was a donation propter nuptias. Evaluate the validity of the donation, taking into consideration the relevant provisions of the Family Code.