Question

1. In 2021, Anna and John got married. Prior to their marriage, Anna's parents gave them a house and lot as a gift. The deed of donation stated that the donation is propter nuptias. Unfortunately, their marriage was short-lived and they decided to get a divorce. Anna now wants to claim ownership of the property, while John argues that the donation is void. Discuss the validity of the donation propter nuptias and its effect on the ownership of the property.

2. On their wedding day, Mark and Sarah decided to donate a valuable antique jewelry set to their favorite charity. The donation was solemnized in a public instrument attesting to their marital agreement. However, after a few months, Mark discovered that Sarah was still legally married to another person when they got married. Mark wants to void the donation on the ground that Sarah did not have the legal capacity to donate. Analyze the validity of the donation and the effect of Sarah's lack of legal capacity on the donation.