Philippine Bar review · Question

Practice question: Exempting Circumstances (See also RA 9208, Sec. 17, as amended; RA 9262, Sec. 26; RA 9344, Sec. 6, as amended by RA 10630)

Multiple Choice Hard

Practice question

A court, with the specified expert assistance, finds that a victim-survivor was suffering from battered woman syndrome in the statutory circumstances. The prosecution argues that she must nevertheless fail solely because ordinary self-defense unlawful aggression was absent. Which is best?
  1. Every abuse allegation conclusively establishes the syndrome
  2. The experts replace the court’s legal determination
  3. Only ordinary self-defense can ever be considered
  4. The statute preserves civil liability in every BWS case
  5. Section26 expressly protects the judicially established BWS case notwithstanding absence of the ordinary self-defense elements, including its criminal and civil-liability consequence

Legal references

  • RA9262, Section26: https://lawphil.net/statutes/repacts/ra2004/ra_9262_2004.html

Answer this question in flashcards to review your response and continue practicing.